College Advising, career path exploration and application support

College Admissions Myths and Scenarios:
Talk That Can Cloud Your Decision-Making

At Collegemind we Can Clear Up Your Confusion

Common College Admissions Myths | Morris Plains, NJ

Many people claim to have knowledge about college admissions, sharing ideas that are respectfully but emphatically untrue. Unfortunately, these misconceptions are widely accepted as fact. The result? College bound students and their parents make decisions based on these inaccuracies — even when they are irrelevant to the situation.

These myths can distract you from your goal, and leading you down paths that disrupt your college process. At Collegemind, we cut through the confusion and provide a clear path.

What you need is a personalized approach that works for YOU in the admissions process.

We've identified 10 common myths and scenarios that can interfere with your decision-making. If you want to know the real deal in college admissions, check out these 10 untruths — then reach out to us and get on solid admissions footing with our Collegemind solutions.

Myth #1

It's all about getting into the most prestigious school.

College Selection Not true!

Your success depends on what you make of your college experience — not the school name on your degree.

Graduates from all types of colleges achieve incredible things because they've chosen schools that align with their goals, values, and personalities. This experience becomes the catalyst for them doing great things in their life and career.

Know that and ditch the pressure of applying only to big-name schools.

Myth #2

Perfect grades are a must for college.

Perfect Grades Believe it or not, this is not true.

While strong grades are important, colleges look at much more than academics.

Schools want dynamic students who are curious and contribute to their campus communities — not just straight-A students. Essays, recommendations, and extracurriculars all show who a student is beyond the numbers.

If you're worried that your grades aren't "good enough," let me show you how much you have to offer.

Myth #3

The More Extracurriculars the Better.

Extracurriculars NO! It's not about doing everything.

Colleges want to see depth and commitment. They care about quality and continuity, not quantity.

A few activities that reflect your passions and leadership are far more impactful than a long haphazard list of clubs.

If you're feeling overwhelmed trying to do it all, Collegemind can help you focus on what most matters to you.

Myth #4

College Planning Starts Junior Year.

College Planning No, to the contrary. Time is of the essence.

Many families wait until junior year to start thinking about college, but that's too late when you have to develop a plan and create a cohesive profile.

It's helpful to begin laying a foundation about college admissions as early as freshman year.

Exploring interests and skills early allows students to build a cohesive story through their coursework and activities, setting them up for success when it's time to apply.

Myth #5

You have to take a certain number of Advanced Placement (AP) and International Baccalaureate (IB) Classes

AP Classes Not so! There's no magic number of advanced courses required.

Colleges want to see that students challenge themselves within their school's offerings.

Excelling in subjects that align with your interests creates a stronger academic profile than overloading on AP courses just to check a box and impress a school's admission's staff.

Find the right balance and plan a schedule that works for you.

Myth #6

Only straight-A students get into top colleges.

Straignt A False! Colleges value RIGOR, growth, resilience, and an upward trend in grades.

They also want students who demonstrate creativity, leadership, and community impact. Success isn't just about a "perfect" transcript.

Don't obsess about being perfect. You might be more prepared than you think!

Myth #7

Liberal Arts colleges don't prepare you for careers.

This couldn't be further from the truth. Liberal Arts colleges emphasize critical thinking, communication, problem solving, and adaptability — skills employers value across every industry.

Graduates succeed in diverse fields and advanced studies.

Don't overlook these incredible schools. By exploring them, you will broaden your horizons.

Myth #8

Paid summer programs boost your application.

Paid Summer Programs Not all summer programs carry the same weight. While selective programs are impressive, many paid programs at top-tier schools don't impact admissions.

What matters more is how a student meaningfully spends their time, not just where they spent it.

Make it count.

Myth #9

Applying to more schools increases your chances.

Apply To Too Many Colleges Admissions isn't a lottery. A robust application sumitted to balanced list of reach, match, and safety schools tailored to a student's goals is far more effective than applying to dozens of colleges.

Focusing on too many applications can diminish their quality.

Quality applications make a stronger impression than quantity.

Myth #10

Rankings are the ultimate guide to choosing a college.

Rankings Important Absolutely incorrect! Rankings don't tell the whole story.

The best school is the one that aligns with a student's values, needs, and long-term goals and allows them to develop meaningful relationships.

It's important to focus on what really matters.

We used Kristen this past spring and summer to help my daughter, Elana, organize her goals for college, develop a strategy for applying, edit her essays, and generally stay on track with deadlines. Kristen has made all of this possible. She helped my daughter examine what she wanted to do after school, what she wanted to learn and what she was good at. Kristen was able to help Elana marry that with a list of schools that perfectly matched her needs. I never worried once about being on track or if we were making the right choices because Kristen kept me informed every step of the way. My daughter completed all of her college essays well before her deadline and now we are in the enviable position of being able to relax and wait for a reply. I can highly recommend Kristen Tarantola and her Collegemind service.

Liz (Parent)

Take
The First
Step

Taking the first step with Collegemind Counseling is as easy as 1-2-3:

Click "Lets Get Started" to Schedule a Call.

Complete onboarding kit with your child's goals and preferences.

Engage in our PathFinder process.

Free Consultation